For customers
Got a Sidewalk Snow Ticket in NYC? What to Do Next
How a DSNY summons for an unshoveled sidewalk works, how to pay it or fight it at OATH, what happens if you ignore it, and how to avoid the next one.
A ticket for an unshoveled or icy sidewalk is a summons from the Department of Sanitation (DSNY). DSNY lists the fine as $100 for a first offense, $150 for a second and $250 for a third or later one. You don't settle it with DSNY, though. Summonses like this are decided by the city's Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, known as OATH.
Here is how it works and what your options are. This is general information, not legal advice. The date and instructions printed on your own summons come first.
First, find your hearing date
Every summons has a hearing date on it. Everything else depends on that date. OATH's hearings page explains each option, and most of them have to happen before that date.
Option 1: Admit it and pay
If you agree you didn't clear the sidewalk in time, you may be able to admit the violation and pay the penalty. OATH says the payment has to be made before the scheduled hearing date to avoid a default. You can pay online through OATH.
Option 2: Fight it
If you think the ticket is wrong, OATH gives you a few ways to tell your side:
- By phone. This is how most hearings happen now. You have to request a phone hearing at least 3 business days before your hearing date.
- Online or by mail. If your case is eligible, you can send a written defense. Online, it has to be in on or before the hearing date. By mail, it has to reach OATH before then.
- In person. Email OATH at least 5 business days ahead to ask for one.
- A new date. If you need more time to get ready, you can ask to reschedule once.
What to think about before you fight it
The rules give you a set amount of time after the snow stops, not after it starts:
- Snow stops between 7:00 AM and 4:59 PM: 4 hours.
- Snow stops between 5:00 PM and 8:59 PM: 14 hours.
- Snow stops between 9:00 PM and 6:59 AM: by 11:00 AM.
If you think you were ticketed before your time was up, that is worth raising. So is anything that shows the path was clear, such as dated photos. Our guide to NYC's sidewalk snow rules covers what counts as cleared, including the four-foot path, hydrants and curb cuts.
Don't ignore it
If you don't respond by the hearing date, OATH says you'll be found "in violation" by default, and "a higher fine may be imposed." If a penalty stays unpaid, the city can go further: it may send the debt to a collection agency, enter a judgment against you in Civil Court, or stop you from getting or keeping a City license or permit.
If you already missed your date, OATH has a way to ask to reopen a missed hearing. Do it as soon as you can.
How to avoid the next one
- Know your deadline before the storm ends. Check when the snow is forecast to stop, then count forward.
- Have salt and a shovel ready. If ice won't come up, salt or sand is what the rules ask for.
- Line up help before it snows. Our snowstorm checklist walks through the day before, the day of and the morning after.
On SnowCrew you can post a scheduled job before the storm with a "done by" time ahead of your deadline. A shoveler nearby books it and takes "before" and "after" photos you can check from your phone. Hiring help doesn't change who the city holds responsible, so look at the photos before you approve the job. SnowCrew is free on iPhone and Android.
Frequently asked questions
Who handles a sidewalk snow ticket in NYC?
The summons comes from the Department of Sanitation (DSNY), but it's decided by the city's Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH). Your options depend on the hearing date printed on the summons.
How do I fight a sidewalk snow ticket?
OATH lets you have a hearing by phone (request it at least 3 business days before your hearing date), send a written defense online or by mail if your case is eligible, or ask for an in-person hearing by emailing at least 5 business days ahead. You can also ask to reschedule once.
What happens if I ignore it?
OATH says you'll be found in violation by default and a higher fine may be imposed. An unpaid penalty can be sent to a collection agency, turned into a Civil Court judgment, or stop you from getting or keeping a City license or permit.
I missed my hearing date. Can I still do anything?
Yes. OATH lets you ask to reopen a missed hearing online. Do it as soon as you can.